Siding Nailer vs Roofing Nailer: Key Differences Explained

Last Updated on November 26, 2024 by John Patterson

To the naked eye, all those nail guns look largely similar.

However, the application is different across each of the nailers.

Indeed, it is often quoted that ‘necessity is the mother of invention.

You see, with siding jobs, there is no need for fasteners like framing nailers. For siding, you need the proper strength to work with wood and vinyl so the nail guns should be at least able to deliver that force.

Likewise, about roofing assignments and working with asphalt shingles and fibreglass —you need a particular nail gun to perform the task proficiently.

In order to get this optimal result while getting rid of all those problems which a person faces during a particular job, the manufacturers have been creating separate nail guns specific to that task.

Siding Nailer vs Roofing Nailer

In this guide, I am going to talk about siding nailer vs roofing nailer and the pros and cons of each of these types of guns.

Without wasting a moment, let us jump in.

What is a Siding Nailer?

 

If you want a more complex answer to the question, it is just a nail gun that perfectly complements siding jobs.

But there is a little more explaining to do with the siding nailer.

Use for: A siding nailer is made to work best with wood or vinyl siding.

That means you need a nailer that doesn’t push the nails into the wall too hard when tackling that task. Plus, the nails are a bit unique for siding jobs. Aligning guns are designed to do all these types of jobs.

All of those problems that a person faces using any type of rough nail gun such as a framing nailer are solved with the use of a siding nail gun.

There is no need to put on a rubber dome as all these siding guns are protected in the front with rubber.

Thus, it does not damage softwood in the case of continuous nailing and equal suitability for hardwood.

Designed to drive siding nails, a siding nailer is lighter-weight and equipped with a depth adjustment system and just the right amount of power in shooting nails for siding.

Siding Nailer Special Features and Benefits

• Ideal for using well, siding nailers are considerably lighter than heavy guns such as framing nailers. You can go abstrain to get it done right.
• It provides adjustable depth. The depth can be adjusted according to your needs. Consequently, you will have an identical shot in the siding over and over again.
• Mainly its base is secured with elastic to manage softwood and hardwood.
• Unlike the framing nailer which shoots nails with plenty of energy, a siding nailer gun provides just enough power to shoot nails for siding.
• One of the best high-quality siding guns would be to have a trigger lock system so that gun is not fired accidentally.
• The siding nail gun is available in a different weight based on your requirement and comfort (Heavy, medium & light).
• There is no hassle using a siding nail gun as most come with air filtration. It reduces the potential of bringing dust into the tool.
• Most pneumatic siding nailers do not need a high-pressure air compressor to run them.

Siding Nailers Drawbacks

• It cannot hit the surface with high pressure. This is the reason it does not work for that sort of work, as is required with harsh and powerful usage of nail tools such as framing did unit.
• The nail head on a siding nailer does not accommodate much.
• It can’t drive coil nails. Hence, for longer-duration jobs, you need to reload the magazine several times.

What is Roofing Nailer?

 

A roofing nailer, as the name implies, is specifically designed to handle all of your roofing tasks.

Generally speaking, when it comes to fastening fiberglass or asphalt shingles on the roof, a roofing nailer is as useful to you as a pocket is to a shirt.

Different types of nails are accepted by these nailers. For roofing, you need a nail that can be easily removed It must also hold shingles tightly.

Roofing nailers shoot coil nails, and you typically do not have to refill the magazine as often. Because it is indeed a hectic job to refill the magazine too often while working on a rooftop.

Take note, any task other than roofing cannot be done with a nailing gun.

Roofing Nailer Special Features and Benefits

• Where you cannot do roofing with any other nail guns and staplers other than a roofing nailer.
• Coil nails can be driven by a roofing nail gun. As a result, it allows you to not have to reload the mag for quite some time.
• A roof is a roof no matter if you are doing it new or re-doing your roof and a roofing nailer works efficiently in both cases.
• Roofing guns are relatively light and quiet when in operation.
• It loads fast.
• Many roofing guns incorporate a trigger lock to prevent accidental shooting
• The handle of all the best roofing guns has an ergonomic shape and a comfortable rubber grip.
• Most of the premium quality units come with an adjustable shingle guide to save you the hassle of bringing in loads of shingles.
• Unlike the pneumatic roofing guns, you will NOT need a high-pressure air compressor to run them.

Roofing Nailer Drawbacks

• Limited Versatility: It’s only used for roofing tasks which is why it’s called a roofing nail gun.
• It’s relatively heavy.
• A few of the roofing guns lack a depth-adjustment system.
• Roofing nailers are prone to jamming a lot.

Roofing Nailer vs. Siding Nailer: Which One is Better for your projects?

Each tool serves a purpose (roofing and siding). After going through my article you will know which works for which type of task.

That being said, allow me to do a side-by-side comparison against some critical aspects.

For weight– Siding nailers vary from light to heavy. But they are lighter than other types of nailers available. Roofing nailers, on the other hand, are typically heavier than siding guns.

Siding jobs should be done with a siding gun and roofing work with a roofing nailer. Using them interchangeably will offer you no uptake.

Roofing nail guns are made specifically for asphalt shingles, fiberglass, insulation board, waterproof tar paper etc. But siding guns are perfect for dealing with vinyl and wood.

Coil nails can not be driven with siding guns. On the other hand, roofing nailers use coil nails.

A depth-adjustment mechanism is a regular feature of siding guns. However, other roofing nailers do not have this feature.

These are roofing guns that can drive in coil nails, so they do not need to be refilled as often. However, they cannot drive coil nails and require multiple refills for extended jobs.

Both these (nailers for siding and roofing) types(2) of tools are run by low-pressure air compressors.

Both cases incorporate trigger lock mechanisms, provided that numerous of the high-quality models possess as well.

Frequently Asked Questions

It is all about having the right tools tacked to your tool belt when embarking on your next home improvement project and for siding and roofing it makes a world of difference. Both involve attaching materials to a house, but knowing what a siding nailer does that a roofing nailer does differently can save you time, energy, and money.

Whether you’ve worked in construction for decades or you’re thinking about DIY-ing a project for the first time, this guide will help you answer your biggest questions. From how these tools work to whether roofing and siding nails are interchangeable, we have the answers.

Read on for how these tools differ when to use which, and how to get the best results of each every time.

Can you use roofing nails for siding?

It might seem convenient to use roofing nails for siding, but this isn’t a recommended approach for most projects. Roofing nails are mostly for shingles, shorter in length, and have a large head. They’re designed to last in the weather, but they may not hold on tightly enough for siding jobs.

Siding nails, however, are longer and thinner, with a smaller head. They have these traits that allow them to penetrate deeper without splitting the material, thus more suitable for siding applications.

Key Takeaway:

Always use the correct type of nail for the job. Roofing nails can destroy the integrity of your siding.

Can a roofing nailer be used for siding?

In theory, a roofing nailer can be used for siding, but it’s not the recommended tools for the job. Roofing nailers are designed for sashing shingles, not siding panels. Their specific design propels nails with large heads that may crack or split siding materials.

The accuracy needed for siding, particularly for vinyl siding, demands the ability to set both nail depth and pressure, a feature available on siding nailers but not often on roofing nailers.

What Not to Use — Why You Should Not Use a Roofing Nailer for Siding:

Vinyl siding: The hammering power of a roofing nailer can crack its surface.

Wood or fibre-cement siding: You are courting inconsistent results or eventual instability.

Best Practice:

For a siding project, a siding nailer is worth the investment.

Can you use a framing nailer for siding?

Another tool that may jump into your mind for your project is these framing nailers. For siding applications, though, they’re generally overkill — while they work great for framing tasks. Framing Nailers are made to drive bigger nails and are not engineered for siding materials, therefore not having accurate measurements.

If you’re framing or settling thinner, more fragile pieces of siding, using a framing nailer may split materials and/or give you an unfinished look.

Best Uses for Framing Nailers:

• Building frames.
• Heavy-duty wood construction.
• Structural assemblies.

What They’re Not Built For:

• Finely detailed work, e.g. siding.

Can you use a siding nailer for roofing?

A siding nailer should not be used for roofing. A siding nailer is configured for precision work and has no tolerance for the specific needs of roof shingles. Because roofing nails tend to have to hold down asphalt shingles or other heavy material in the longterm, they often need to go very deeply into the material as well, requiring special tools for roofing, such as a roofing nailer that has a proper depth adjustment.

Why You’ll Need a Roofing Nailer When Roofing:

• Larger head for improved shingle holding power
• Intended for boring nails into shingles for the lasting fastening—when it is inclement outside.

Stick to the Right Tool:

Roofing installation with a siding nailer is guaranteed to lead to poor and shaky roofs while blowing warranty on roofing materials.

Can I use siding nails in a roofing gun?

While it may sound as though it would be a quick work around, using siding nails with a roofing gun is generally impractical. Roofing guns usually use shortnails with a large head, which will not work with longer, thinner siding nails.

You will likely have functional issues with jammed nailers, uneven placement, and damaged installation quality. Using nails and nailers that are mismatched may also affect safety and cause other malfunctions with the tools.

Bottom Line:

Use the recommended types of nails for each tool to avoid wasted efforts (or worse), a lack of safety, or a decrease in durability.

How many siding nails per square?

The number of siding nails you’ll need to use per square foot will depend on the type of siding you’re putting on. The average amount is about 2 nails per panel per stud approximately every 16 inches. For a 100-square-foot siding job, you might need about 200 nails, although specific needs can vary based on the siding material as well as the manufacturer’s recommendations.

Pro Tip: Consult your siding manufacturer for specific fastening instructions suitable for your project, particularly to cover installation practice for your warranty.

Roofing and siding nails are different, right?

Roofing and siding nails might look the same at first sight but are intended to be used for completely different things.

Are roofing and siding nails the same?

Head Size: The head on a roofing nail is wider to increase grip. Siding nails have a smaller head to prevent any material damage.

Length: Siding nails are generally longer, designed to penetrate through siding panels and into the sheathing for secure fastening. Roofing nails are shorter to effectively secure on shingles.

Material: Roofing nails tend to be galvanized or coated to resist rust and the elements. Occasionally, siding nails are made of stainless steel for increased rust-resistance.

Choosing the Right Nail:

Using the right kind of nail will give you a long-lasting, high-quality finish. Nails that don’t match won’t last, creating problems like material warping, cracking or loosening.

Why You Need to Choose The Right Tool?

Whether installing siding or roofing, the tools and nails you use affect the quality, speed and durability of your job. Here is a brief overview of when to use each tool:

It’s best to use a siding nailer for siding work so it crisps out properly, the nail or staple is-shot properly and less damage is done to the surrounding area.

Count on a roofing nailer for roofing shingles to give you a firm grip against outdoor elements.

Reserve power tools like framing nailers for projects that need heavy-duty nails, such as structural framing.

Getting the right tools for the job smooths the workflow and lasts longer so you don’t have to do it again.

Make Your Next Project a Hit

With this guide, there is no need for you to feel overwhelmed while deciding between a siding nailer and a roofing nailer any longer. Knowing the specific features and functions of both tools will prepare you for success with any home improvement project.

Have questions about the best tools or techniques? Share any in the comments, or consult with a local hardware expert before your next purchase.

Final Words

I am sure by now you have figured out that siding nailer vs roofing nailer is no longer a debate.

These two guns are indeed meant for two distinctly different tasks, and that is very obvious.

Regardless, you have to select either a high-quality siding nailer or the best-quality roofing nailer as per the application that gives optimum results.

Related Posts
#1.Pin Nailer and Brad Nailer Differences.
#2. Brad Nailer and Finish Nailer Differences.
#3. Pneumatic and Cordless Nail Gun Differences.
#4. Siding Nailer and Framing Nailer Differences.