Pin Nailer Vs Finish Nailer: Pros, Cons, [+FAQs]

Last Updated on December 2, 2024 by John Patterson

Whether you are a professional carpenter or an avid DIYer, choosing the right nailer can enhance the quality and efficiency of your projects. In woodworking, both pin nailers and finish nailers are two of the most common choices. But when do you use one over the other? What advantages and disadvantages do they each have?

If you are looking to clear your confusion and help you determine the tool you will need for your next projects, keep reading. This complete guide will cover the differences between pin nailers and finish nailers, along with their uses, advantages, and disadvantages.

Overview of Pin Nailer and Finish Nailer

A pin nailer is a small hand-held power tool, and it is often confused with a finish nailer, because they are both power tools used to join workpieces, especially for wood or finish carpentry. Though they both have similar purposes, they are different in design, type of nails, function and suitability.

Pin Nailers are virtually undetectable and great for precise work, such as with trim or veneer.

Finish Nailers, by contrast, are capable of delivering more power so they can work with thicker, heavier materials like baseboards or molding.

Ultimately, it all depends on your project’s requirements—are you doing fine detail work or do you want structural integrity?

What is a Pin Nailer?

A pin nailer is a lightweight, extremely accurate nail gun that uses 23-gauge headless nails (a.k.a. pin nails). These leave no noticeable holes, so they’re great for projects that need a perfect finish.

Pin nailers do not typically have the holding strength of bigger nailers. This makes them ideal for secondary attachment, in which adhesives serve as the primary bonding material.

What is a pin nailer used for?

Pin nailers are great for lightweight woodworking projects, and frequently function in an aesthetic rather than structural capacity.

When to Use a Pin Nailer?

• Attaching fragile trim without splitting the wood
• Joining thin slivers of veneer to a surface
• Making intricate wood objects
• Put the final coats on detailed cabinet work

Pin Nailer Best For:

• Softwood trims
• Thin veneers
• Small decorative moldings
• Light, precision projects

Pin Nailer Pros

• Results in small, almost undetectable holes
• Stops creasing in fragile materials
• Ideal for precision work
• Super light and maneuverable,

Pin Nailer Cons

• Not for heavy or structural work
• Nails do not have much-holding power
• Generally not suitable for larger or thicker materials

What is a Finish Nailer?

A finish nailer is a more heavy-duty, versatile tool that shoots 15- or 16-gauge nails with small heads. These nails provide a stable grip for heavier material while still allowing for a professional aesthetic.

Finish nailers are primarily used in trim carpentry and other high-freezing projects.

What can a finish nailer be used for?

Most well-known for addressing moderate heavy-duty applications, such as structural and decorative work.

When to Use a Finish Nailer?

• Installing baseboards
• Installing door and window casing
• Securing crown molding
• Crafting furniture or cabinetry
• Heavy-duty finish carpentry projects

Finish Nailer Best For

• Baseboards
• Crown molding
• Door and window trims
• Moderately light duty woodworking items

Finish Nailer Pros

• Nails that are strong for firm fastening
• Adaptable uses for diverse substances
• Ideal for big, heavy trims
• Gives a finished look to long-lasting projects

Finish Nailer Cons

• Holes from larger nails that might require filling
• Heavier than pin nailers, so not as good for intricate work
• More probable to fracture small or fragile items

Comparison Table Between Pin Nailer and Finish Nailer

Pin Nailer Vs Finish Nailer: Which Nailer Should You Use?

Which one to choose, pin nailer or finish nailer, is entirely dependent on what type of projects you are looking to do.

Use a pin nailer, if you want to attach very delicate trims, wood veneers or thin decorative pieces and need a flawless appearance.

Select a finish nailer, if your project includes baseboards, molding, or medium-to-heavy carpentry duties where strength and durability are a must.

If you’re juggling multiple types of projects, being able to wield both tools is a game changer, providing you with flexibility and precision when it matters most.

Using Nailers: Important Tips

Safety First: Always use protective goggles and follow the manufacturer’s instructions.

Use the Correct Nails: The right nail gauge and length should match your tool and the material being fastened.

Nail First: If you are not sure, drive some nails through scrap material to see if you split the wood or mar the surface.

Fill Nail Holes: Finish nail holes can be filled with wood putty, sanded, and painted for a professional appearance.

Take Care of Your Tool: Clean and oil your nailers so they stay in peak condition.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use a pin nailer for trim?

Yes, Yes, a pin nailer is a great option for delicate or light wood trims where the nail holes want to be hidden.

Can you use a pin nailer for baseboards?

The short answer is no, pin nailers are not recommended for baseboards. Their nails do not have the holding strength necessary for heavier materials.

Can you use pin nails in a Brad nailer?

No, pin nails are 23 gauge and are specific to pin nailers. Brad nailers normally take 18-gauge nails, which are a wider diameter and are small-headed.

Does Milwaukee make a pin nailer?

Yes, Milwaukee does have pin nailers in their cordless lineup.

What’s the difference between brad nailer and finish nailer?

A brad nailer drives thinner, 18-gauge nails that have less holding power, so they are useful for lighter work. Finish nailers shoot 15- or 16-gauge nails, for heavier-duty projects.

How to fasten trim — What Size Finish Nails For Trim?

It varies with how thick the trim is, but most experts suggest using 1.5-inch to 2.5-inch finish nails for standard trim jobs.

What size trim finish nailer?

When it comes to actually installing trim, read on for the nail guns you’ll need: A 15-gauge or 16-gauge finish nailer is usually the best way to go.

Make Every Project Count

Whether decorative work or heavy-duty carpentry, the right nailer can take your project to the next level. The pin nailer is great for the accuracy and invisibility of fine details, and the finish nailer drives them home, adding durability and strength for heavyweight tasks.

Use the proper tools and your woodworking projects will stand tall! Happy building!